The law relating to contracts of guarantee is governed by Sections 126 to 147 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. A guarantee is a contract to perform the promise or discharge the liability of a third person in case of his default. In commercial and financial transactions, guarantees play an important role in securing credit and ensuring repayment obligations.
One important type of guarantee recognized under the Indian Contract Act is the Continuing Guarantee. Since continuing guarantees may cover a series of future transactions, the law also provides rules regarding their revocation. Sections 129 and 130 specifically deal with continuing guarantees and their revocation.
Meaning of Guarantee
Under Section 126 of the Indian Contract Act, a contract of guarantee is a contract to:
- Perform the promise, or
- Discharge the liability of a third person in case of his default.
The parties involved are:
- Surety – the person giving the guarantee,
- Principal Debtor – the person whose default is guaranteed,
- Creditor – the person to whom the guarantee is given.
Example
If A guarantees repayment of a loan taken by B from C, then:
- A is the surety,
- B is the principal debtor,
- C is the creditor.
Meaning of Continuing Guarantee
Section 129 of the Indian Contract Act defines a continuing guarantee as:
“A guarantee which extends to a series of transactions is called a continuing guarantee.”
Thus, when a guarantee is not confined to a single transaction but applies to multiple future transactions over a period of time, it is called a continuing guarantee.
Features of Continuing Guarantee
1. Covers a Series of Transactions
Unlike an ordinary guarantee limited to one transaction, a continuing guarantee applies to successive dealings between the creditor and principal debtor.
2. Continuing Liability
The surety remains liable for transactions occurring within the scope of the guarantee until the guarantee is revoked.
3. Future Transactions
It generally applies to future transactions and obligations rather than a single completed transaction.
4. May Be Limited or Unlimited
A continuing guarantee may:
- Be limited to a fixed amount, or
- Extend to unlimited transactions depending on the contract terms.
Illustration of Continuing Guarantee
Example 1
A guarantees payment to B for goods supplied on credit to C from time to time up to ₹1,00,000.
This is a continuing guarantee because it covers a series of future supplies.
Example 2
A guarantees payment for a single loan taken by C from B.
This is not a continuing guarantee because it relates only to one transaction.
Essentials of a Continuing Guarantee
For a valid continuing guarantee:
- There must be a valid contract of guarantee,
- The guarantee must relate to a series of transactions,
- There must be consideration,
- Consent of parties must be free,
- The guarantee should not be unlawful.
Nature of Liability in Continuing Guarantee
The liability of the surety under a continuing guarantee is:
- Co-extensive with that of the principal debtor unless otherwise provided,
- Continuous until revoked,
- Applicable to all covered transactions occurring before revocation.
Under Section 128, the liability of the surety is generally co-extensive with the liability of the principal debtor.
Advantages of Continuing Guarantee
Continuing guarantees are commercially useful because:
- Creditors obtain security for recurring transactions,
- Businesses can obtain continuous credit facilities,
- Repeated execution of fresh guarantees becomes unnecessary.
Banks frequently use continuing guarantees in:
- Cash credit accounts,
- Overdraft facilities,
- Running business accounts.
Revocation of Continuing Guarantee
Since a continuing guarantee may extend indefinitely, the law allows revocation under certain circumstances.
Revocation means cancellation or termination of the guarantee concerning future transactions.
The Indian Contract Act provides two principal modes of revocation:
- Revocation by notice,
- Revocation by death of surety.
1. Revocation by Notice – Section 130
Section 130 provides:
“A continuing guarantee may at any time be revoked by the surety, as to future transactions, by notice to the creditor.”
Thus, the surety may revoke the guarantee by giving notice to the creditor.
Features of Revocation by Notice
1. Applies Only to Future Transactions
Revocation affects only future transactions occurring after notice.
The surety remains liable for:
- Transactions entered into before revocation,
- Existing obligations already incurred.
2. Notice Must Be Given to Creditor
The revocation becomes effective only after communication to the creditor.
3. No Effect on Past Liability
The surety cannot escape liability for transactions already completed before revocation.
Illustration
A guarantees payment for goods supplied by B to C up to ₹50,000.
B supplies goods worth ₹30,000 before revocation notice.
After A gives notice revoking the guarantee, B supplies additional goods worth ₹10,000.
A remains liable only for ₹30,000 supplied before revocation and not for later transactions.
2. Revocation by Death of Surety – Section 131
Section 131 provides:
“The death of the surety operates, in the absence of any contract to the contrary, as a revocation of a continuing guarantee, so far as regards future transactions.”
Thus, death automatically revokes the continuing guarantee for future transactions unless there is an agreement otherwise.
Effect of Death
1. Automatic Revocation
No separate notice is necessary unless contractually required.
2. Liability for Past Transactions Continues
The estate of the deceased surety remains liable for obligations incurred before death.
3. Contract to the Contrary
The parties may expressly agree that the guarantee will continue even after death.
Illustration
A guarantees future credit transactions between B and C.
A dies after B has already supplied goods worth ₹40,000 to C.
B later supplies additional goods worth ₹20,000.
A’s estate is liable only for ₹40,000 and not for the subsequent supply unless the contract provides otherwise.
Modes of Revocation Distinguished
| Basis | Revocation by Notice | Revocation by Death |
|---|---|---|
| Governed by | Section 130 | Section 131 |
| Method | Express notice | Automatic by operation of law |
| Applies to | Future transactions | Future transactions |
| Past Liability | Continues | Continues |
| Communication | Necessary | Generally not necessary |
When Continuing Guarantee Cannot Be Revoked
A continuing guarantee cannot generally be revoked:
- For liabilities already incurred,
- After rights of the creditor have crystallized,
- Where specific contractual provisions restrict revocation.
Difference Between Specific Guarantee and Continuing Guarantee
| Basis | Specific Guarantee | Continuing Guarantee |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage | Single transaction | Series of transactions |
| Duration | Ends after one transaction | Continues until revoked |
| Revocation | Generally unnecessary | May be revoked |
| Nature | Limited | Continuous |
Discharge of Surety in Continuing Guarantee
Apart from revocation, the surety may also be discharged under other provisions of the Contract Act.
1. Variance in Terms of Contract
Under Section 133, material alteration in terms of the contract without the surety’s consent discharges the surety.
2. Release of Principal Debtor
Under Section 134, discharge of the principal debtor may discharge the surety.
3. Composition or Promise by Creditor
Under Section 135, arrangements between creditor and debtor without surety’s consent may discharge the surety.
4. Loss of Security
Under Section 141, loss of securities held by the creditor may discharge the surety to that extent.
Important Judicial Decisions
Offord v. Davies
This important English case established that revocation of a continuing guarantee applies only to future transactions and not to past liabilities.
Hasimara Industries Ltd. v. Union Bank of India
Indian courts have recognized that continuing guarantees remain enforceable according to their contractual terms and revocation principles under the Contract Act.
Practical Importance of Continuing Guarantees
Continuing guarantees are extensively used in:
- Banking transactions,
- Corporate finance,
- Commercial credit arrangements,
- Loan facilities,
- Trade transactions.
Banks often require directors or third parties to execute continuing guarantees for company borrowings.
Modern Commercial Relevance
In modern commercial practice:
- Continuing guarantees provide financial security,
- Creditors rely upon them for long-term business relationships,
- Sureties must carefully understand extent and duration of liability.
Improperly drafted guarantees may result in prolonged financial liability for sureties.
Rights of Surety after Payment
After discharging liability, the surety acquires:
- Right of subrogation,
- Right to recover from principal debtor,
- Benefit of securities held by creditor.
Thus, the law seeks to protect the surety from unfair loss.
Conclusion
A continuing guarantee under Section 129 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 is a guarantee extending to a series of transactions rather than a single transaction. It plays an important role in commercial and banking transactions by providing continuing security for future dealings between creditor and debtor.
Since such guarantees may potentially continue indefinitely, the law permits revocation through notice under Section 130 or by death of the surety under Section 131. However, revocation affects only future transactions, and the surety remains liable for obligations incurred before revocation.
The provisions relating to continuing guarantees balance the interests of creditors, debtors, and sureties while ensuring certainty and fairness in commercial transactions. Understanding these principles is essential in modern banking, finance, and contractual law.
Leave a Reply